George Adava Ayo

Department of History and International Studies,

Federal University Lokoja,

Lokoja, Kogi State

george.ayo@fulokoja.edu.ng

&

Ezeeala Martins Ifeanyi

Department of History and International Studies,

Federal University Lokoja,

Lokoja, Kogi State.

Abstract                                               

The delivery of quality health care is crucial to achieving enhanced health benefits, patient safety and a positive patient experience of healthcare. This study is aimed at providing insight on the quality of the healthcare delivery in Nigeria, and to if quality healthcare in Nigeria is a reality or a myth, using Abuja Municipal Area Council as a case study, from 2017-2022. The study adopts a historical approach by relying on primary sources, which include the extraction of information from some hospitals in the area and secondary data by use of journals, articles, reports, periodical and etc. The study attempts to clarify some concepts and is carried out in a thematic format, where issues raised will be discussed under themes and sub-themes. The discuss is tailored along an established framework of treatment, effectiveness, acceptability, efficiency and the appropriateness of the means of delivery as well as equity. It is to examine if quality systems in health care delivery in Nigeria is a myth or a reality, using the available data in Abuja. It would determine if there is need to galvanize the efforts of relevant stakeholders including the patient in charting a new agenda for healthcare quality improvement in Abuja, in terms of treatment effectiveness, acceptability of the healthcare services efficiency, the appropriateness of healthcare and equitable service delivery in Nigeria.

Keywords: Delivery, Quality, Healthcare, myth and Reality.

875 KB

INTRODUCTION

Health is a fundamental human right. Article 25 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights grants everyone: the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and his family, including food, clothing, housing and medical care and necessary social services.

Health is a multi-dimensional construct with diverse aspects as well as multiple determinants. Among factors that could influence the health outcome is the adequacy of health services which in many settings are designed to be available, affordable, accessible, and appropriate as well as being equitably distributed. These services could be delivered from multi-tier system and from privately or publicly owned health facilities.[1] For either public or private health facilities, there continues to be the concern of whether health services are delivered in a way that guarantees optimal clients and other stakeholders’ satisfaction with services provided.This study aimed atexamining quality of healthcare delivery in Abuja Municipal, by relying on available evidences, which include both primary and secondary, thereby ascertaining if health care delivery in the area is a is a reality or a myth. The review objectives were to describe quality healthcare, the indicators of quality health care as well as the level of quality healthcare along various indicators in Abuja in terms of the various indicators of quality health care. The study is aimed at providing answers to the following questions: what is quality health care? What are the indicators of quality health care? To what extent is quality healthcare in terms of treatment effectiveness, acceptability of the healthcare services, efficiency, the appropriateness of healthcare delivery and equity available in Abuja.

Quality healthcare is one of the most important factors in how individuals perceive their quality of life. In most countries, alongside the economy, it is the major political issue. In some countries, the healthcare delivery organization is a part of the national identity. Research proved that healthcare issue especially primary Healthcare service is an enigma in Nigeria and its citizens are suffering the consequences. Due to the aforementioned, the healthcare system in Nigeria has shown spatial variation in terms of availability and quality of facilities in relation to need. However, this is largely as a result of a number of issues including the level of state and local government involvement and investment in healthcare programs and education.[2]

A critical goal of healthcare delivery in both developing and developed countries is the achievement of sustainable high quality of healthcare at reasonable Cost.This is premised on the assumption that quality can be measured, monitored and improved. The demand for high quality and affordable Healthcare is spurned-up from the ever-evolving demographic, epidemiology and political systems in the world as well as greater complexities in the pattern of diseases and the preferences of the health consumers.[3]Beside the burgeoning influence of consumerism in healthcare, other drivers of quality in healthcare include the knowledge and competence of healthcare provider, patient cooperation, health insurance, leadership and management styles in health facilities, collaboration, available referral system, job satisfaction of the healthcare providers and etc.[4]

According to the 2009 communique of the Nigerian national health conference, healthcare system remains weak as evidenced by lack of coordination, fragmentation of services, dearth of resources, including drugs and medical supplies, inadequate and decaying infrastructure, distribution, and access to care and very deplorable quality of care.[5] According to Health Reform Foundation of Nigeria, the reforms and changes made to retain health security seem not to have made positive effect on the health care system.[6] Considering the threats of health insecurity, there is therefore immense need to revitalize the Nigerian healthcare system and provide specific project design to enhance cooperation and efficiency.

According to the commentary on the National Health Policy 2016, health system is divided into 10 key areas which are; governance and stewardship, health service delivery, health financing, human resources for health, medicines, vaccines, other health technologies, health infrastructure, health information system, health research and development, health promotion, community participation and ownership and partnership for health. All these 10 key areas are created for one goal which is to improve the healthcare system through, funds, making available medicines, vaccines and other technologies.[7]

HISTORICAL BACKGROUND OF AREA ABUJA MUNICIPAL COUNCIL.

Abuja Municipal Area Council (AMAC), was created on the 1st October 1984 located on the eastern wing of federal capital territory. The bulk of federal institution, ministries, embassies are located within the confines of the Area council. The area council is accessible by land, air and telecommunication. The Nnamdi Azikwe International Airport international and domestic flights. The area council is also accessible from other part of the country by road through Suleja road on the North, on the east through arterial Keffi-Nyanya road and through the Lokoja Gwagwalada road on the west The Abuja municipal area council which comprises of twelve wards namely; City operate, Center, Garki, Gui, Gwarinpa, Jiwa, Karshi, Kabusa, Karo, Nyanya, Oronzo and Wuse and each of these wards are represented by an elected councilor. The councilor forms the legislative arm of the area council. The executive arm comprises of an elected chairman and a vice together with an appointed secretary and other supervisory councilors and special adviser. The headquarter is located at Garki and has an area of 1,769 (sq km).

TYPES AND STRUCTURE OF HEALTHCARE SYSTEM INNIGERIA

In Nigeria, there are three levelsof healthcare delivery systems, namely: primary, secondary and tertiary healthcare systems. Each of the healthcare systems in Nigeria addressed varying complexity of health issues. The primary healthcare is managed by the Local Government with the supervision of National Primary Health Care Delivery Agency NPHCDA: Secondary healthcare is managed by the State Government with the supervision of state ministry of health while the Tertiary is managed by the Federal Government with the supervision of the Federal ministry of health.

Primary Healthcare System

In Abuja the primary healthcare is usually the first point of contact for the majority of the population with the national health system. This type of healthcare system comprises primary healthcare centers( PHC) situated in every local government area to bring health closer to the people. Primary healthcare caters to addressing non- emergency, preventative health care issues of the population. Primary health care provides medical evaluations to patients with all types of acute and chronic health issues, provides treatments, promotes health education, and refers patients in need of more specialized services to secondary or tertiary health care.At primary health care facilities, patients are typically seen by primary care physicians (also known as general practitioners or family doctors), however, in some cases, the patients may be first seen by other health care professionals such as a pharmacist or physiotherapist. The proximity of primary health care centers to the population facilitates the continuity of medical care that support full recovery, routine check- ups, and preventive medical care.

The medical professionals at primary health facilities usually possess a range of knowledge in many areas to enable them to provide care to patients of all ages, gender, and medical issue.Unfortunately, the state of primary health care in Abuja is below satisfactory as only 20 percent of the 30,000 plus primary health care systems are fully functional to provide essential primary health care services to the population.[8] The reasons for the abysmal state of the primary health care system in Nigeria include but are not limited to poor staffing, a dearth of medical professionals, poor infrastructure, and the lack of a regular supply of essential drugs.

Secondary Healthcare System

Secondary healthcare occupies   the second tierin health care delivery system, this level of care provides both general and specialized health care in the health facilities, it focuses on providing in-patient specialist treatment and support to those who have been referred from primary healthcare with conditions beyond the scope and competence of the workers at the primary health centers. The healthcare professionals in secondary healthcare facilities specialize in helping patients who struggle with more complex health condition that require specific expert care such as pneumonia, cancer, severe infections, and broken bones. At secondary healthcare facilities, patients are usually seen by medical professionals with expertise in their unique health challenges.[9] Some of the specialist medical professionals in secondary health care include psychiatrists, cardiologists, pediatricians, gynecologists, the medical services offered by secondary health care include medical evaluation, diagnostics, treatments, and surgical interventions. In Nigeria, this level of health care system accounts for a substantial amount of medical services to the Nigerian population since some patients usually opt for secondary health care system when the primary healthcare facilities are unable to cater to their basic medical needs. Although most secondary healthcare facilities require that patients possess prior referrals from primary healthcare centers before being attended to, others do not.

Tertiary Healthcare System

The tertiary health care system is the highest form of specialized medical care in Nigeria. Patients with complicated and more severe health are usually referred to tertiary healthcare facilities by primary and secondary healthcare systems. The sort of medical care provided in tertiary healthcare systems is mostly performed by medical professionals with expertise and more specialized state-of-art equipment. The medical services performed in the tertiary health care system include the management of diseases, neurosurgery, diagnostics, cardiac surgery, palliative interventions, transplant surgery, intensive care, palliative interventions, diagnostics, and moreThe healthcare facilities that undertake tertiary healthcare in the country are the Federal Teaching and Specialist Hospitals which are situated in every state across Nigeria. Some examples of tertiary healthcare facilities in Nigeria include Lagos University Teaching Hospital, University of Port Harcourt Teaching Hospital, University of Uyo Teaching Hospital, University College Hospital Ibadan, University of Abuja Teaching Hospital and National Hospital Abuja among others.

The state of healthcare delivery in Nigeria falls short of being satisfactory, especially in primary health centers (PHCs) and secondary health care systems. The reasons for the deficiency in the country’s health system stem from several factors. First is the lack of adequate funding for the health sector. In April 2001, members of the African Union (AU) met in Abuja concerning the deplorable condition of health care in their countries. To close the gap, the AU agreed upon the Abuja Declaration which stipulated that a minimum of 15 percent of the budgets of member countries be allocated to health care. For 21 years since the Abuja Declaration, none of the health care allocation from the national budget has ever been up to the agreed-upon15 percent.

CHALLENGES OF HEALTHCARE DELIVERY IN ABUJA NIGERIA.

Healthcare delivery in Abuja is saddled with series of challenges, ranging from the Poor infrastructural facilities, lack of awareness on the part of patients, inadequate provision of healthcare equipment, insufficient man power.

Poor Infrastructural facilities.

A basic challenge to healthcare delivery in Abuja is the deplorable condition of infrastructural facilities in many of the areas or communities under the Municipal. Some of the facilities are either abandoned mid-way to completion, dilapidated or entirely rendered unusable by health care practitioners which of course affects health care delivery in such places for instance, at the entrance to Gui, a community in the Abuja Municipal Area Council of the Federal Capital Territory, is a building just beside the community’s primary healthcare centre which based on observation is at the lintel stage, is old from its look and structurally inadequate for an efficient health care delivery facility. The building, undoubtedly, is another failed effort of the government aimed at ensuring better service delivery, especially in the area of primary healthcare since it had not deemed it fit to complete the structure.

Also, primary healthcare is an area managed by the area councils in the Federal Capital Territory since they are the nearest link of the government to the grassroots. But over the years, in many rural communities in the FCT, quality healthcare services proved hardly accessible to residents with many going long distances to obtain it since the ones available are not in good condition.Unlike some communities, Gui has a primary health centre but the centre is a far cry from the recommended standard[10]. The building is old, the floor cracked, and the facilities faulty.[11]  The poor state of things in the building, prompted the need for having a new center, which was built just beside the old one. But as soon as the building reached the lintel stage, the contractor had left the building unattended, hence the health care facility remains poor and the other one has been left unattended, and this is a major infrastructural challenge.

Projects such as the Gui in question is estimated to be worth multi-million naira, and while some equipment and facilities for the centrehave already been delivered, including an ambulance, since the beginning of the project in 2005 up till now, it has not been completed[12] among other major ways this challenge affects the people of the community is that residents have to go to Gwagwalada and some nearby private hospitals for their health needs as the center cannot attend to serious cases despite several reports and requests to the government for support and help to revitalize the healthcare facility.[13] To further support the above assertion, Shehu Salisu[14], a resident of the area in an interview disclosed that he does not patronize the health centre, but prefers traveling or going to neighboring communities where there are more efficient private hospitals.

Aside the facility itself, there are several other equipment that are requisite for prompt health care delivery such as monometer, some of which though were delivered for the purpose of equipping the hospital when it is completed, the delay in the construction had caused many of such equipment to spoil beyond usage, hence unable to serve the people any longer, and thus affecting healthcare delivery effectively.[15]Other notable equipment include toilet facilities in the centre, electricity and water which are nothing to write home about, hence the need for the building to be renovated[16].

Insufficient Manpower

Another challenge is that man power is insufficient, and this means that many people can not be adequately attended to. In Gwosa community for instance, the man power is not enough and is essentially understaffed, especially because many medical workers that are supposed to serve the centre are having more than one engagement and works in more than one hospital.[17]In cases of emergency only very few staff are always around to give required healthcare to patients. At Kuchingoro Primary Health Centre, Abuja Municipal Area Council a doctor attends to more than 30 patients between 7am and noon[18].

Inadequate funding of healthcare facilities

Consider that the Federal ministry of health usually spends about 70% of its budget. Urban areas where only a shabby 30% of the population resides, what an existential irony. What is worrisome is that a lot of money has over the years been pumped into these teaching hospitals yet not much is there for Nigerians to rejoice about in their Primary Healthcare Services.

The federal allocation for the health sector is laughable in a country with no infrastructure to carry the most basic necessities such as steady power for hospital equipment (where available), good roads to transport patients to and from the hospitals, emergency medical service and personnel (if you dial emergency number, you’re on your own), or even water for proper sanitation. The wards in some of the hospitals are so run down and bare they look like they would be sources for new outbreaks of diseases. To worsen the situation, allocation of funds never makes it through intact as the greedy leaders meant to utilize it for the welfare of the people pare it down to a small fraction of its original size.

Poor Remuneration and Welfare Packages

This had over the years contributed to the exodus of Nigerian Doctors and other health personnel abroad in search of better opportunities. Indeed, Doctors, Nurses, and Healthcare workers In these institutions are paid mere pittance not commensurate with the high level or stress and daily exposure to the diseases in the high level of stress and daily exposure to the diseases in the health centers. Some of them do not get paid for months at a time, when they are the frontline workers in the healthcare system as it is in Nigeria today.The salaries and welfare packages of Doctors and other Healthcare workers have been burning issues in recent years. Early this year, public hospitals were paralyzed due to strikes by medical doctors over poor welfare packages. Doctors and health workers in Nigeria are the lowest paid. Nigerians want government to address the issue of doctors pay by implementing a universal doctor’s salary scale in order to avert frequent strikes by them. Doctors in Abuja had sometimes in past paralyzed health services in public hospitals for over three weeks over the issue of new salaries.

CONCLUSION

Quality health is vital in any country, not only for the purpose of maintaining a healthy populace, but also as a matter of national security. A healthy country is a wealthy country; with a thrivinghumanresource the country can invest in, to move the nation to greater heights. Saying that the Nigerian health sector is in shambles is tantamount to saying the sky is up above. This is the unadulterated truth, fact, reality, right-in-your-face, that Nigerians have to contend with, in addition to the other litany of inconveniences. Nigeria hasa shortage of doctors and health care workers. There is less amount of funds invested in the health care system. The health workers are severely unpaid in Nigeria. Record keeping for health care is poor. Nigerian government spends about 15% of its annual budget on healthcare.

Despite having some of the very best healthcare professionals in the world, the

lack of development of the public healthcare system has eroded the little confidence the general population have in the Nigerian healthcare system. Even the leaders who ought to lead by example are quality of this lack of faith in the Nigerian healthcare system, which is why they excel at flying themselves and their cronies to other countries with highly developed healthcare systems at the Slightest sign of any health issues. This is basically why doctors, nurses, and healthcare workers in these institutions are paid a mere pittance not commensurate with the high level of stress and daily exposure to the diseases in the high level of stress and daily exposure to the diseases in the health centers. Some of them do not get paid for months at a time, when they are the frontline workers in the healthcare system as it is in Nigeria today.

The suffering is real, a trip to Primary Health Centers in Nigeria, especially to Abuja Municipal Area Council Health centers as case study, will sober even the most jaded person. The queues are long, the equipment outdated, the facilities understaffed, the necessary medication is often lacking, and most of the patients cannot even afford the drugs or treatment. Remote areas and rural Communities are almost relegated to the background and have to fend for themselves. Some of these areas are not even connected to the national grid, and so have no power whatsoever. The manner of drug supply is also cause for concern. Most of the drugs in the Health Centers within the area Council are not regulated, even the tomato seller could also sell medication like pain killers, multivitamins and tetracycline.

In view of the above, my candid opinion is that strategic actions such as revamping the health sectors, especially the Primary Healthcare Centers should be paramount to government of the day at all level in order to deliver adequate and sustainable health services to the citizenry. Also, prioritizing the basic minimum package delivery through National and State-driven Insurance Schemes are important in filling up policy gaps for optimizing healthcare delivery. But without strong actions against corruption in Nigeria, quality healthcare delivery in remains aspirational and not realistic.

RECOMMENDATIONS

The Healthcare System of a country works to provide timely and best medical facilities to the citizens of a country. Nigerian Healthcare System is run by three tries of government, where the Federal Government manages tertiary healthcare, State government manages secondary healthcare and Government is responsible for Primary Healthcare.

The followings are the ways to improve the Primary Healthcare system in Nigeria:

  1.  Health Campaigns

The most practical way to improve the Nigerian Healthcare System is by organizing health campaigns and spreading awareness about diseases, their cure, and prevention. When citizens are aware of the diseases, prevention and Cure then only a country can be saved from diseases. Similarly supporting SERVICOM to effectively carry out its duty of bridging the gap between health care performance and the expectation of patients in health facilities is necessary.

Also Focus on Primary Health Centers (PHC) and State Primary Healthcare Development Agency (SPHCDA) to oversee the development of strong community engagement and participation at the primary health centers via the following steps: Build a community engagement platform and identification of functional PHC in each local government area spread across the geo-political zones in the country. Identification of community health committees at each local government area. These committees, which are important drivers for health care demand, should comprise of a wide spectrum of persons from the respective local government. They should include religious leaders, teachers, chiefs, members of the town’s royalty, adolescents, civil society organization, volunteers from the women’s group and men’s group. Awareness about NHIS; Citizens of Nigeria must be aware of NHIS. Only 4% of people were covered under NHIS in the year 2016[19]. Efforts should be made to cover more and more people under NHIS. It will have the best possible results in the Nigeria health care delivery system.

  • Ensuring Expertise Treatment

Adequate Health Treatment is necessary, Government should ensure that all health workers are professionals in order to obtain effectiveness and efficiency in healthcare delivery.

  • Provision of Sufficient Drugs to the Primary Health Centers

Considering the fact that Primary Healthcentresdeal directly to the people at the grassroots and majority of the citizens reside in the rural Communities where these healthcare services are predominantly located, there is need for the provision of sufficient drugs that are necessary for quick intervention and medical care.

  • Provision of Social Amenities

Government should ensure that social amenities such as electricity, water, etcneed to be functional and steady within the Health centers, in order to increase and maximize public health in Nigeria.

  • Capacity Building training of Health Workers

investing in training of more medical staff and other Health workers is required to alleviate current facility burdens, prioritizing continuous medical education for Healthcare staff to improve their knowledge base and improving awareness campaigns regarding healthcare advice for the population.

  • Increase of Budgetary Allocations

The major challenges in the healthcare sector have to be overcome by increasing the national budget allocation (% per GDP) for Healthcare to match the global standard.[20] Government should also increase the funds given to the Health sectors and monitor the funds till it gets to the final destination as required, it will help to improve our Health sector and reduce exodus of Nigerians seeking medical care outside the shores of the country

  • Setting up Goals and Committing Evaluation

Analyzing patient’s data and setting goals is another innovative way or improving health structure of a country. Prioritize the areas and set up goals. Then committing to ongoing evaluation is a must.

  • Improving Food Supply and Nutrition

Good nutrition is the key to good health. Many diseases can be used just by having proper and good nutrition. If the government focuses on food supply, then many things could change in Nigeria. Pregnant women, growing children, breast feeding mothers need more nutrition and care but due to poverty people cannot afford better food and nutrition. The infant fertility rate can also be monitored by improving food facilities in Nigeria.

  • Eliminating Corrupt Practices

Corruption is an endemic that has eaten deep into the fabric of Nigerian health system, for the improvement of the healthcare sector, all corrupt elements need to be decimated. A measurement of the extent of sector-level involvement corruption is required. Appropriate tools must be harnessed to assess the impact and to track corruption in the health sector. Tools including assessments of vulnerability, Public Expenditure and Financial Accountability Indicators (PEFA), Public Expenditure Tracking Surveys and Reviews (PERS) are useful the Ministry of Health is to adopt a combination of top-down as well as down-top approaches against corruption[21]. Resistance to a top-down approach will be complemented by a corresponding community led down-top approach with media sensitization campaign for the general public on the awareness of a fight against corruption in the health sector. Multi-sectoral collaboration and partnership with the anti- corruptionagencies in the country including the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC), Independent Corrupt Practices Commission will be essential in enforcing sanctions against corrupt practices in the health sector. This is to connect the policy to broader policies against corruption in the country.


[1]Car J. The Impact of Health “on the Quality & Safety of Healthcare: A Systematic Overview & Synthesis of the Literature. Report for the NHS Connecting for Health Evaluation Programme. Extended Executive Summary”. University of Edinburgh2008.

[2]Hegarty J, Savage E, Cornally N, Byrne S, Hen P, Flynn M, Fitzgerald S. A Systematic Literature Review to Support a Framework for the Development of Standards for Clinical Practice Guidance. University College Cork, Ireland. Available online at: www.health.gov. ie/patient-safety/ncec. 2015.

[3]Omachonu V. K. Einspruch N. G. “Innovation in healthcare delivery systems: a conceptual framework. Innovation”Journalof Public Sector Innovation. 2010.

[4]Lambo E. “Primary health care: realities, challenges and the way forward.” A Paper Presented at the First Annual Primary Health Care Lecture. Abuja. 2015.

[5]Chinawa J. M. “Factors militating against effective implementation or primary health care (PHC) system in Nigeria”. Ann Trop Med Public Health. 2015

[6]Health Reform Foundation of Nigeria, “Federal Republic of Nigeria. National Health Policy (2016) Federal Republic of Nigeria” 2010.

[7]Fatusi A. O.“Nigerian health system, Public health leadership, policy development and the Nigerian health system”.  A Paper Presented at the Induction Program of the Institute for Government Research Leadership Technology. Abuja: 2015. Available from: http://www.instituteforgovernmentresearch.org

[8]Bilqis B. A. Emmanuel O. Owolabi L. K. “Determinants of patient satisfaction on service quality dimensions in the Nigeria teaching hospitals”. Economics management innovation. 2015.

[9]Omoruan A. I. Bamidele A. P. Phillips O. F.“Social health insurance and sustainable healthcare reform in Nigeria”. Ethno Med. 2009

[10]Ransome-Kuti O. “Who Cares for the Health of Africans?: The Nigerian Case’ International Lecture Series on Population Issues”. Kaduna, Nigeria: The John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation. 1998.

[11]Interview with Akuso Zakariyyah Junior Community Health Extension Worker, Gui, Abuja, Nigeria

[12] Interview with Alhassan Yusuf the District Head, Gui Community health centre, Abuja.

[13] Interview with Alhassan Yusuf the District Head, Gui Community health centre, Abuja.

[14] Interview with Shehu Salisu, resident of Gui Community, Abuja.

[15] Interview with Akuso Zakariyyah, a volunteer worker at the primary healthcare

[16] Interview with Ayuba Abdullahi, Mabushi Community deputy chairman, Abuja Municipal Area (AMAC).

[17] Interview with Akuso Zakariyyah, a volunteer worker at the primary healthcare

[18]Taiwo Adeniyi, Mustapha Suleiman Daily Trust, Wed, 15 Oct 2014

[19]Okoli U, Eze-Ajoku E, Oludipe M, Spieker N, Ekezie W, Ohiri K. “Improving quality of care in primary health-care facilities in rural Nigeria: successes and challenges”. Health Services Research and Managerial Epidemiology. 2016

[20]Iroju O, Gambo I, Ikono R, Olaleke J. “Interoperability in Nigeria Healthcare System: The Ways Forward”. I.J. Information Engineering and Electronic Business. 2013

[21]Okoli U, Eze-Ajoku E, Oludipe M, Spieker N, Ekezie W, Ohiri K. “Improving quality of care in primary health-care facilities in rural Nigeria: successes and challenges”

Leave a Comment