Egwuaba, Edward Ukwubile, Ph.D

Department of Sociology

Chukwuemeka Odumegwu Ojukwu University, Igbariam

edwardegwuaba@yahoo.com/eu.egwuaba@coou.edu.ng

&

Sunday, Blessing Adeyi

Department of Sociology,

Prince Abubakar Audu University; Anyigba

sundayblessingadeyi@gmail.com

 Abstract

This paper investigates the CBN Naira Re-Design Policy and theExploitation of Awka Residents by Business Owners. It examined the implications of naira redesign on the over-exploitative activities of Business owners on residents of Awka metropolis, assessed the public perception of the naira redesign and its consequences on Awka residents and explored how these changes have impacted on the lives of Awka residents and Nigerians. This study also relied on the phenomenology theory of Edmund Husserl and Alfred Schurtz to explain the social phenomena reviewed. The study adopted the descriptive survey research design and used both the quantitative and qualitative methods to generate data from a sample of 120 respondents selected via purposive random sampling techniques. Results indicate that naira redesign has had a significant effect on the exerting criminal behavior by business owners in Awka and that this has in turn influenced the social reality of Nigerians during the period under review. The paper concludes amongst others that naira redesign should be effectively managed in order to limit the influence of criminal elements on the country’s economic and social progress. Based on the aforementioned findings, the study suggests that policy makers should take into consideration the implications of currency redesign when formulating and in implementing economic strategies.

Keywords: Business-owner’s, Consequences, Exploitation, Metropolis, Naira-Redesign.

814 KB

Introduction

The currency of every nation has a tremendous effect on the economy and remains one of those distinguishing features of a nation. According to Ndujihe (2023), in a monetized economy like Nigeria; money is a viable tool for economic transformation, growth and progress. The optimum distribution of economic resources and the efficient functioning of a modern economic system would not be possible without the monetary apparatus which, by and large enables the government to provide the governed with basic social amenities and perform other related functions for the benefit of the country.

The Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) recently undertook a redesign of the country’s national currency, the Naira. The main goal of the redesign was to combat counterfeiting and enhance the security features of the currency, which generated widespread interest from all and sundry, while others were concerned about the potential cost and challenges associated with the transition (Pillah, 2023). The benefit of the redesign, on the other hand, are believed to include improved public confidence in the currency, a reduction in the number of fake naira notes in circulation, and enhanced security features that will make it more difficult for criminal elements to produce counterfeit notes, as well as well as to provide a boost to the Nigerian economy (Odior, 2022; Nwanma, 2023).

As the Central Bank of Nigeria’s Naira redesign policy bites harder, the scarcity of new notes continues to disrupt business activities in markets, restaurants, banks, and major sales outlets across the states of the federation with the citizens resorting to any available means to sustain their existence even to the detriment of others. In midst of the operational challenges being faced by small businesses across the length of the country, Point of Sale (PoS) transaction charges jumped almost 500 percent in most cities across Nigeria, especially in Awka metropolis, Anambra State. The impact of the CBN policy and its attendant chaos have frustrated efforts by many Anambrarians and generally Nigerians operating in the nation’s cash-dependent informal economy to do business, make payments, and enjoy certain services. It is therefore against this background that this study investigated the impact of the CBN Naira re-design policy in the criminal exploitation of residents of Awka metropolis by business owners.

Objectives of the Study

The study sought to:

  1. Assess the public perception of the naira redesign and its impact on Awka residents.
  2. Examine the implications of naira redesign on aiding the over-exploitative activities of Business owners in Awka metropolis.
  3. Explore the changes that have impacted on the lives of Awka residents and national development.

Conceptual Clarification

Currency redesign is an activity of a sovereign nation to either change or modify the existing currency in a country. This can be done for several reasons like; improving the security features of the new currency, reducing the money supply, reducing inflation, investigating incomes from nefarious sources and many other economic indicators that affect the financial status of a nation.

Brief Literature Review

The Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) announced that the bank would release re-designed naira notes by December 15, 2022, while existing notes would cease to be regarded as legal tender by January 31, 2023. Through this policy, the apex bank aims to control the money supply, and inflation, as well as, curb counterfeit currency. Also, the apex bank noted that available data indicated that N2.73 trillion out of the N3.23 trillion currencies in circulation was outside the banking system and supposedly, held by members of the public (Central Bank of Nigeria, [CBN], 2022).Monetary policy is adopted by the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) to stimulate collective demand through adjustable changes in money supply and interest rate. It also plays an important role in the redesign of the currency. The purpose of the currency redesign is to mop up the huge amount of cash that is outside the banking system, which currently estimated at 2.73 trillion or about 85% of the total cash in circulation (Nwanma, 2023). Economic factors driving the redesign of the Naira include lowering inflation, thwarting counterfeiting, reducing insecurity, and increasing the amount of money in circulation, as it is believed that 85% of all the country’s cash is hidden away in houses outside of the banking system. Amassoma, Keji and Emma-Ebere (2018), explained that monetary policy is a vital tool which could be used to achieve currency management, price stability, and strengthen the growth of investment.

The redesign of currency has beneficial and detrimental economic implications. Currency redesigns increase a currency’s security by helping nations keep counterfeiting to a minimum and stay one step ahead of threats (Nwanma, 2023). Additionally, it is anticipated to boost the economy, lower cash management costs, advance financial inclusion, and improve the government’s ability to monitor the money supply. Analysts say redesigning the naira has decreased proactive pressure and suppressed insecurities in Nigeria. It will diminish the money stock and, as a result, slow the long-term course of inflation by reducing the amount of currency held outside of banks. Interest rate reductions may result from the ensuing deflationary pressure, which will stimulate economic activity in the short to medium term, increase aggregate demand, and improve output growth. Analysts contend that redesigning the naira, which was implemented close to the 2023 general elections, may have lessened the inclination to buy votes.

Conversely, according to international experience, rapid demonetizations might result in short-term costs, with small enterprises impoverished and vulnerable people likely suffering the most because they are cash-constrained and heavily reliant on daily cash transactions. Existing naira notes being phased out over a short period could make things more difficult for households and businesses, who already face significant financial pressures from prolonged, high inflation, which have recently been exacerbated by external shocks on the price of food and fuel, as well as the severe floods (Ochei, 2022).

Studies show that currency redesign is a good approach to manage the money in circulation (International Monetary Fund, 2022; Murphy, 2023; Okoye, 2023). It is hoped to minimize the
influence of money on the country’s electoral process thereby discouraging vote-buying and
inducement of electoral officers. However, scholars like Pllah, 2023, and Coyle, Kim & O’Brien, 2021 have argued that the timing of this exercise in Nigeria is always wrong, and this paper cannot agree less. Literatures available revealed that the CBN always plans to execute the currency redesign to effectively manage the flow of the currencies (Central Bank of Nigeria, 2015). And the short period notice is put in place to penalize those hoarding or laundering the Nigerian currency.

Money plays a very crucial role in the economy of a nation. Without money, no business both in the private or public sector can thrive or survive because it is needed for the day to day running of businesses as well as taking care of personal related daily expenses. People at the helm of affairs in the government ministries, parastatals, industries, companies, etc with corrupt tendencies and mindsets have always device ways to hoard the naira notes in their quest to amass wealth for themselves, their children and their generations yet unborn. This leads to the proliferation of money laundering cases in Nigeria. Currency hoarding does not allow enough money to flow and this as a result impedes the smooth running of economy and also brings about high cost of living.

Monetary policy is enacted by a central bank to sustain a level economy and keep unemployment low, protect the value of the currency, and maintain economic growth hence the redesign of the naira. However, some Nigerians are bemoaning their fate because of the hardship this new Naira design palaver is causing in the country, and they feel that the timing of the implementation is wrong even if the intention is genuine. The real threat is that elections is a major logistics venture that is capital intensive. As a parting gift to most Nigerians, President Buhari, in his wisdom, has decided that the current generation of Nigerians must also suffer the trauma of emergency currency change which the older generation suffered in 1984. His idea then, as it is today, is that it is a method to catch looters of the national treasury who will be forced to reveal their stolen monies. The problem then, as it is today, is that whatever the approach’s merits are, there is massive collateral damage among the masses.

Nigeria has in the past, had reasons to change, redesign and redenominate its currency; but, never, in the annals of the nation’s political history, has such an exercise brought so much hardship, confusion, apprehension, rancour and despondency, it is no longer being witnessed and experienced. Despite the potential benefits, there have been concerns about the cost of the redesign and the challenges associated with transitioning to the new notes. Some have argued that the cost of the redesign will be passed on to consumers in the form of higher prices, while others are concerned about the potential confusion and inconveniences that may arise during the transition period (Olabimtan, 2023).

Theoretical Framework

This study is anchored on the Phenomenology theory of Edmund Husserl (1859-1938).Phenomenology is a philosophical theory developed by the German philosopher, Edmund Husserl (1859-1938) and his disciple Alfred Schultz (1889-1959), an Austro-American businessman and social philosopher who in combining Husserl ideas with those of G. H. Mead, developed phenomenology as a leading school of interpretative sociology in the late 1960s and 1970s. He held that phenomenology has two meanings: Firstly, it is an object of perception, something we see, feel or perceive through our senses. Secondly, however, a phenomenon is something “extraordinary,” something out of the normal which we cannot yet explain or understand-a spiritual force, an ESP (extra sensory perception) (Schutz,1972). The first definition is the scientific everyday one based on the assumption that the world around us actually exists and has a reality of its own that we perceive objectively, through our senses, while the second definition is the interpretative view, that life from the physical world having a reality of its own, we, through our senses, make sense of it and so in a sense recreate it according to our interpretation.

Applying this theory to the study, drawing from the both definitions of phenomenology in relation to the issue of CBN naira redesign policy and its attendants impact, business owners in Awka metropolis, perceived that an opportunity existed in the naira redesign policy that could allow them to criminally to over exploit the residents, made sense of made of such perception and recreated it by increasing withdrawal charges by over 400percent as well as the extra charges put on items bought by residents to make illicit profits that left residents suffering and gnashing through their teeth while such exploitation and cash crunch lasted.

Methodology

Study Location/Population/Research Design

The study was conducted in Awka Metropolis of Anambra State, Nigeria, between February and May, 2023. The study adopted the descriptive survey research design with both quantitative and qualitative techniques and made use of the two-stage sampling procedure. The study population comprised of residents of Awka local government area in Anambra State, Nigeria.The study population comprises of 120 business owners as well as others engaged in various occupations including (male and females) from the age of 15 years and above in Awka, Metropolis, Nigeria. As regards sample size and sampling technique, the study utilizes two stages sampling techniques. The first stage involves the selection of businesses and money cash points operators in the study area, with each selected area allotted 60 samples. The second stage involves selection of sample of 60 respondents from each of the selected districts in the study area, and they were all chosen as sample for the study using purposive sampling techniques which brought the total to 120 respondents selected for the study.

Method of Data Collection/Analysis

Data was generated from the field through structured questionnaire. Descriptive statistics was used for data analysis using the Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) version 25, and statistically analyzed using frequency tables and simple percentage to describe the socio-demographic characteristics, and other substantive issues raised in the study. Out of the 120 questionnaire administered to the selected respondents, so the analysis and presentation of results/findings was based on the 120 questionnaires that duly retrieved from respondents in the study area.

Result: Results/Findings 

Table 1: Socio-Demographic Characteristics of Respondents’ (N=120)

Variable                                                            Category                Frequency   Percentage (%)
SexMale                              75                             62.5                                                                                                         Female                         45                            37.5                                        Age in years                                                            15-24                           25                            20.8                                                                                                               25-34                           45                            37.5                                                                                                       35-44                           30                            25.0                                                                                                         45 & above                  20                            16.7                                Marital Status                                            Single                            38                            31.7                                                                                                       Married                         56                            46.7                                                                                                              Widowed                      19                           15.8                                                                                                                   Divorced                        7                             5.8                                      Level of Education                                               No Formal                       8                             6.7                                    Primary                         21                           17.5                              Secondary                     36                           30.0                                  Tertiary                         55                           45.8                                             Occupational Status                                               Unemployed                    3                             2.5                      Student                          27                           22.5                                                                                         Trading/Business38                           31.7                                              Civil Service                   52                           43.3                  Average monthly income       Less than 20, 000          8                            6.7         20,000-30,000              10                            8.3                      31,000-40,000              24                           20.0                            41,000-50,000              30                           25.0                             51,000 & above            48                           40.0                               Total                                                                                                                    120                          100.0

Source: Field Survey, 2023

Table 1 above show that majority of the respondents constituting 75(62.5%) were males, while the remaining 45(37.5%) were females. Findings reveal that more female than male participated in the study. On the age distribution of the respondents, a little less than half of the respondents representing 45(37.5%) were aged between 25-34 years, 30(25.0%) were within the age of 35-44 years, 25(20.8 %) were aged 15-24 years, while those aged 45 years and above were 20(16.7%) years old. The marital status of the respondents, show that most of them representing 56(46.7%) were married, 38(31.7%) were single, a few others 19(15.8%) were widowed, while the remaining few 7(5.8%) were divorced. Findings revealed that more married couples followed by single persons 31.7% were involved in the study.

Furthermore, the educational attainment of the respondents show that majority of the them constituting 55(45.8%) were tertiary educational qualification representing followed by a few respondents with holders of senior secondary school certificate 36(30.0%), 21(17.5%) were holders of primary school certificate, while the remaining 8(6.7%) of the respondents had no formal education. Equally, results show that majority of the entire respondents representing 52(43.3%) were in the civil service, 38(31.7%) of the respondents were into trading/business owners who are self-employed, 27(22.5%) of the respondents were students, while the remaining 3(2.5%) of the respondents were unemployed. From the findings, it is likely due to the fact that majority 43.3% of the respondent are people who earn fixed amount as salary even though the prices of goods and services keeps increasing without a corresponding increase in salaries are being illegally exploited and cheated of their hard earned money by business owners who saw the Naira redesign chaotic situation as an opportunity to make more money exploitatively.

Finally, the income level of the respondents show that most of them representing 24(20.0%) earned between 31,000-40,000 naira per month, 10(8.3%) earned between 20, 000-30, 000 naira monthly, 48(40.0%) of the entire respondents earned between 51, 000 thousand naira and above, 8(6.7%) of the respondents earned less than 20, 000 naira per month, while the remaining 30(25.0%) of the respondents earned between 41,000-50,000 naira monthly. Findings reveals that the general take home pay of two-third of the respondents were meagre and yet business owners are still busy illegally exploiting residents of Awka metropolis.

Table 2: Responses on the Perception of the Impact of Naira Redesign in Awka Metropolis (N= 120)

Variable                                              Category                             Frequency   Percentage (%)
In what ways were Awka        Business owners seized Residents shortchanged or          the situation to rip people off of their Exploited by business owner’s   hard earned money via criminally and especially POS Operators    exorbitant charges on transactions                          40                     33.3                                                        PoS Operators were charging 5,000                                                      Naira as withdrawal fee for 15, 000 Naira,                                                      30, 000 naira for withdrawing 100, 000                                                      Naira, 2,000 naira charge for  withdrawing                                                      5,000 naira and 4, 000 Naira for withdrawing                                                      10, 000 Naira respectively                                     56                    46.7                                                        Food item seller’s compelled customer’s                                                      to include extra charges to the actual amount                                                      of wares bought to cover withdrawal cost           24                    20.0 Total                                                                                                                         120             100.0

Source: Field Survey, 2023

Table 2 above, results revealed that a little less than half of the respondents representing 56(46.7%) expressed that Business owners and PoS Operators’ took advantage of the CBN Naira Redesign Policy to thoroughly exploit the residents of Awka metropolis. They were criminally charging residents 5.000.00 Naira for a 15,000.00 Naira withdrawal which was originally 300.00Naira, 30,000.00 Naira for a 100,000.00 Naira which was hitherto charged for 1,000.00Naira, 2,000.00 Naira for withdrawing 5,000.00 Naira which was 100.00Naira, and 4,000.00 Naira for a 10,000.00 Naira which ordinarily cost 200.00 Naira respectively, but all these changed due to the CBN Naira redesign policy by bringing grave sufferings and hardship on the people of Awka metropolis.

Corroborating that above findings, an In-Depth Interviewee relayed that:

“Due to the scarcity of both the new and old naira notes, some business owners and POS Operators over hiked the withdrawal charge from N100 for N5, 000 withdrawals to N2, 000 fee for N5, 000 withdrawals, as they looked to profit from the scarcity which they saw as once in a life time opportunity to usurp people.” (Female/29 years/Students/IDI/April, 2023).

Another In-Depth Interviewee indicated that:

“The market women sold cash for you with big interest so that PoS attendant will also add big interest to make profit. This is a great corruption affecting the whole Nigerians.” (Female/34 years/Civil Servant/IDI/May, 2023).

Also, a few of the respondents, 40(33.3%) opined that Business Owners as did PoS Operators, capitalized on the CBN Naira Redesign policy to criminally rip off Awka metropolis residents of their hard earned money through outrageous charges on cash withdrawal’s and on any item bought from their shops, while the remaining few others, 24(20.0%) of the respondents indicated that food item sellers in the markets and various stalls available made their customers to include extra charges to the actual amount of wares bought from them to cover their own withdrawal cost whenever they so decide to withdraw their business money. This findings above clearly shows that Awka residents especially the civil servants and the working class were exploited given that their salaries were fixed and consequently lost more money from the meagre amount they got at the end of each month.

Table 3: Responseson the Implications of the CBN Naira Redesign Policy on Nigerians (N= 120)

Variable                                           Category                                   Frequency Percentage (%)
Has the CBN Naira redesign            Yes                                                     117                  97.5 policy had any implications on Nigerians and Nigeria?                      No                                                         3                    2.5   What kind of implications has it  The terrible suffering and the untold had on Nigerians and Nigeria?      hardship brought upon citizens              30                   25.0                                                         Economic loss Nigerians and Nigeria                                                       had witnessed of the faulty implement-                                                       ation of the CBN Naira redesign policy  40                  33.3                                                         Triggered economic disruption and diffi-                                                       culty, especially for rural dwellers who                                                       do not enjoy banking services                   35                29.2                                                          It cost billions of tax payers’ money the                                                        Cover the cost of CBN Naira redesign    15                 12.5   Total                                                                                                               120              100.0

Source: Field Survey, 2023

Table 3 above, result shows that majority of the respondents constituting 117(97.5%) asserted that the CBN Naira redesign policy has had some remarkable implications on Nigerians and Nigeria, while the remaining 3(2.5%) of the respondents responded in the negative. Findings reveals that a vast majority of Nigerians felt some negative impacts of the CBN policy on their general well-being despite the intended benefits of the policy.

Furthermore, on the kind or type of implication the CBN Naira redesign policy had on Nigerians and Nigeria, few of the respondents 30(25.0%) indicated the terrible sufferings and the untold hardship the CBN policy brought upon Awka residents and Nigerians, less than half of the respondents representing 40(33.3%) averred that the economic loss that Nigerians including Awka residents and the nation had experienced due to the faulty implementation of the CBN naira redesign policy, a few of the respondents 35(29.2%) stressed that the CBN naira redesign policy triggered economic disruptions and difficulties for Awka residents, as well as Nigerians, especially the rural dwellers, who do not enjoy banking services.

Lastly, the remaining respondents constituting 15(12.5%) opined that it cost billions of naira of tax payers’ money to foot and cover the cost of producing and designing new naira notes so as to achieve the actualization of the Central Bank of Nigeria’s Naira redesign policy.

An In-Depth Interviewee respondents corroborating the above findings averred that:

“The new naira redesign, he stressed, has triggered varied reactions and feedback that suggest that related issues like the phasing of old currency notes, withdrawal limit, and the scarcity of new notes may have started to impact businesses and social livelihood beyond intentions.” (Female/38 years/Civil Servant/IDI/May, 2023).

Table 4: Responses on the Changes that have Impacted their Lives in Awka Metropolis (N= 120)

Variable                            Category                                                Frequency   Percentage (%)
Did you notice any            Yes                                                                   110                   91.7 Change during the Cash crunch of CBN         No                                                                     10                     8.3 Naira redesign policy?
If yes, what kind of           Cost of transportation/Price of                         20                     16.6 Changes did you witness? food items skyrocketed                                              Civil servants were worst affected by the                                            Naira redesign as they spend more even                                            When their salary is fixed                                50                    41.7                                              Fuel was selling at 480 naira per litre              35                    29.2                                              The network of banks across the state was                                            The worst ever experienced as transfers                                            Could hard go through for days running         15                     12.5   Total                                                                                                          120                   100.0                             

Source: Field Survey, 2023

Table 4 above, on whether the residents of Awka metropolis witnessed some any changes during the cash crunch arising from the CBN Naira Redesign Policy, 110(91.7%) constituting majority of the respondents answered in the affirmative that they experienced some changes, while the remaining 10(8.3%) of the respondents responded not witnessing or experience any change during the cash crunch challenge occasioned by the CBN naira redesign policy. This findings reveals that majority of Awka residents witnessed some changes that probably impacted their life experience and sustenance negatively over the course of the period. Also, on the kind of changes witnessed, a little less than half of the respondents constituting 50(41.7%) opined that government workers/civil servants were the worst hit set of people, as they were compelled to spend more money than they earned given that their salary was fixed due to the over exploitation of Awka residents witnessed during the CBN Naira Redesign Policy which brought with it changes and untold hardship and sufferings on the people during the period.

Furthermore, a few 35(29.2%) of the respondents expressed that fuel was selling for 480 Naira and above per litre across the length and breadth of Awka metropolis during the cash crunch period brought upon the people by the CBN Naira redesign policy, a few others 20(16.6%) of the respondents stressed that the cost of transportation fares as well as prices of food items in the market within and around the environs were tripled which further acerbate the sufferings of residents, while the remaining few 15(12.5%) of the respondents indicated that the network of most banks within and around Awka metropolis were the worst ever witnessed in the state during the said period as many residents could not initiate any transaction on their Mobile Apps without repeated fail, as it took, sometimes 3 to 4 days for such transactions to be successful. From this findings, it can be seen that the CBN Naira redesign policy brought with it, aside its benefits, a change which unleashed untold hardship and suffering on Awka residents and Nigerians in general.

An In-Depth Interviewee respondents confirming the above statement stressed that:

“Nigerians were stranded because the bank apps for transfers needed to be fixed, and most people could not make or receive transferred money for days, it was that bad.” (Male/36 years/Civil Servant/IDI/May, 2023).

Another opined that:

“It was a frustrating situation that I couldn’t pay through transfers or even via PoS Machines at the supermarket where I went to buy my baby food and some items for the house.” (Male/41 years/Civil Servant/IDI/May, 2023).

Discussion of Findings

This study investigated the impact of the CBN Naira re-design policy in the criminal exploitation of residents of Awka metropolis by business owners. From the study, results indicated that most of the respondents were aged 25-34 years (37.8%), those aged 35-44 years (25.0%), and followed closely by those aged 15-24 years (20.8%) respectively. This shows that most of the respondents were in their productive years, which probably accounts for the high level of exploitation give the opportunity presented them by the CBN naira redesign policy. Most of the respondents were married (46.7%), while about (31.7%) of the respondents were single which could imply some level of self-centeredness as a tendency to criminally exploit others. Most of the respondents had tertiary education (45.8%), (30.0%) had secondary education which could account for the number of those in the civil service, while (43.3%) reflected those respondents in the civil service. 40.0% earned between 51, 000 naira and above monthly, 25.0% earned between 41, 000-50,000 per month and 20.0% of the respondents earned between 31, 000-40, 000 naira as average monthly income.

Most of the respondents 56(46.7%) expressed that Business owners and PoS Operators’ took advantage of the CBN Naira Redesign Policy to thoroughly exploit the residents of Awka metropolis. They were criminally charging residents 5.000.00 Naira for a 15,000.00 Naira withdrawal which was originally 300.00Naira, 30,000.00 Naira for a 100,000.00 Naira which was hitherto charged for 1,000.00Naira, 2,000.00 Naira for withdrawing 5,000.00 Naira which was 100.00Naira, and 4,000.00 Naira for a 10,000.00 Naira which ordinarily cost 200.00 Naira respectively, but all these changed and occurred due to the CBN Naira redesign policy by bringing grave sufferings and hardship on the people of Awka metropolis.

Also, a few of the respondents, 40(33.3%) opined that Business Owners as did POS Operators, capitalized on the CBN Naira Redesign policy to criminally rip off Awka metropolis residents of their hard earned money through outrageous charges on cash withdrawal’s and on any item bought from their shops. This findings above clearly shows that Awka residents especially the civil servants and the working class were exploited given that their salaries were fixed and consequently lost more money from the meagre amount they got at the end of each month. The above findings was corroborated by (Okoye, 2023; Nwanma, 2023; Ochei, 2022), who stated that despite the potential benefits, there have been concerns about the cost of the redesign and the challenges associated with transitioning to the new notes. Some have argued that the cost of the redesign will be passed on to consumers in the form of higher prices, while others are concerned about the potential confusion and inconveniences that may arise during the transition period. Result shows that majority of the respondents constituting 117(97.5%) asserted that the CBN Naira redesign policy has had some remarkable implications on Nigerians and Nigeria. Findings reveals that a vast majority of Nigerians felt some negative impacts of the CBN policy on their general well-being despite the intended benefits of the policy (International Monetary Fund [IMF], (2022)

Furthermore, on the kind or type of implication the CBN Naira redesign policy had on Nigerians and Nigeria, few of the respondents 30(25.0%) indicated the terrible sufferings and the untold hardship the CBN policy brought upon Awka residents and Nigerians, less than half of the respondents representing 40(33.3%) averred that the economic loss that Nigerians including Awka residents and the nation had experienced due to the faulty implementation of the CBN naira redesign policy, a few of the respondents 35(29.2%) stressed that the CBN naira redesign policy triggered economic disruptions and difficulties for Awka residents, as well as Nigerians, especially the rural dwellers, who do not enjoy banking services. Supporting the above, Nwanma, (2023), averred that the redesign of currency has beneficial and detrimental economic implications.

On whether the residents of Awka metropolis witnessed some any changes during the cash crunch arising from the CBN Naira Redesign Policy, 110(91.7%) constituting majority of the respondents answered in the affirmative that they experienced some changes, This findings reveals that majority of Awka residents witnessed some changes that probably impacted their life experience and sustenance negatively over the course of the period. Also, on the kind of changes witnessed, a little less than half of the respondents constituting 50(41.7%) opined that government workers/civil servants were the worst hit set of people, as they were compelled to spend more money than they earned given that their salary was fixed due to the over exploitation of Awka residents witnessed during the CBN Naira Redesign Policy which brought with it changes and untold hardship and sufferings on the people during the period.

15(12.5%) of the respondents indicated that the network of most banks within and around Awka metropolis were the worst ever witnessed in the state during the said period as many residents could not initiate any transaction on their Mobile Apps without repeated fail, as it took, sometimes 3 to 4 days for such transactions to be successful. From this findings, it can be seen that the CBN Naira redesign policy brought with it, aside its benefits, a change which unleashed untold hardship and suffering on Awka residents and Nigerians in general.

Conclusion

The Central bank of Nigeria’s naira redesign is generally aimed at achieving specific objectives, including but not limited to: improving security of banknotes, mitigating counterfeiting, preserving the collective national heritage, controlling currency in circulation, and reducing the overall cost of currency management. In spite of the perceived benefits of the 2022 Naira redesign programme by the CBN, theprogramme has had devastating effects on Nigerians, especially rural dwellers and small andmedium scale business owners, who found it very difficult to make transactions amid thecash crunch. The cash crunch was itself furthered by hierarchies of corrupt practices thatbecame hopelessly entangled with the implementation of the programme: the new notes weremostly packed and given to a few privileged Nigerians at the expense of others. The lapses ofthe country’s e-banking infrastructure also became apparent in the absence of sufficient cashcirculation. All these are pointers, not only to the faultiness of the hazy implementation of theNaira redesign programme, but also to the need for renewed efforts in combating corruptionin the Nigerian banking sector; and the need to upgrade the country’s e-banking channels andother infrastructures necessary for the smooth running of a cashless economy.

Recommendations

Based on the above findings of the study, the following recommendations were made:

  1. Policies like this must and should always be thoroughly scrutinized and extensively considered, especially in a nation like Nigeria going through financial crunches. Such financial public policy must be elaborately considered before implementation.
  2. It is suggested that policy makers should take into consideration the implications of currency redesign when formulating and in implementing economic strategies.
  3. The government of Anambra and Nigeria should carry out an intensive investigation to ensure the business owners who grossly and over-exploited Awka residents and Nigerians should through the National and State Assemblies enact a law that deter those who may want cash in on such situations in the nearest future to rip off citizens.

References

Business Day (2022). Naira redesign – the law and global best practices.

https://businessday.ng/news/legal-business/article/naira-redesign-the-law-and-global-

best-practices/accessed on April 13, 2023.

CBN (2015), “History of Nigerian Currency.”, Press Release, 2015. Accessed on 18/04/2023.

CBN (2022), “Issuance of New Naira Banknotes”, Press Remarks by Godwin Emefiele, October 26. Accessed on 18/04/2023.

CBN (2023), “On Progress of Implementation of New Redesigned Currency by The Central  Bank of Nigeria”, Press Statement by Godwin Emefiele, January, 29. Accessed on 18/04/2023.

International Monetary Fund (2022). Currency Crises and Monetary Policy in an Economy.        

Https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/staffp/2000/00-00/ab.pdf. Accessed on the 16th April, 2023.


Morphy, R., (2023), “Nigeria’s Season of Cash Scarcity”, Leadership Newspaper, February. Accessed on 18/04/2023.

Ndujihe, C., (2023), “Vote-Buying: Politicians Plot New Strategies to Bypass Cash Crunch”,
                  Vanguard Newspaper, February 19. Accessed on 18/04/2023.

Nwanma, S. M. (2023), “Currency Redesign: Lessons For Nigeria From Global Best
                 Practices
”, Daily Trust, February, 5. Accessed on 18/04/2023.
Ochei, A. (2022), “Naira Redesign – The Law and Global Best Practices”, Business Day,
                 November, 18. Accessed on 18/04/2023.

Okoye, F. (2023), “ISWAP Distributes N100,000 Old Naira Notes To Each Borno
                 Passenger
”, Leadership, January. Accessed on 18/04/2023.

Olabimtan, B. (2023), “Old N200, N500, N1000 Remain Legal Tender Till Dec 31, Says Supreme Court”, Premium Times, March 3. Accessed on 18/04/2023.

Pillah, T. P. (2023). Currency Redesign and Monetary Policy of Nigeria:An Evaluation.

International Journal of Public Administration and Management Research (IJPAMR),

 Vol. 8, No. 4, 8(4):46-53

Schutz, A. (1972). The Phenomenology of the Social World. London: Heinemann Educational Book.

Leave a Comment